Wikipedia:Requests for arbitration/Rainbowwarrior1977/Evidence

Anyone, whether directly involved or not, may add evidence to this page. Please make a header for your evidence and sign your comments with your name.

When placing evidence here, please be considerate of the arbitrators and be concise. Long, rambling, or stream-of-conciousness rants are not helpful.

As such, it is extremely important that you use the prescribed format. Submitted evidence should include a link to the actual page diff; links to the page itself are not sufficient. For example, to cite the edit by Mennonot to the article Anomalous phenomenon adding a link to Hundredth Monkey use this form: [http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Anomalous_phenomenon&diff=5587219&oldid=5584644] [1].

This page is not for general discussion - for that, see talk page.

Please make a section for your evidence and add evidence only in your own section. Please limit your evidence to a maximum 1000 words and 100 diffs, a much shorter, concise presentation is more likely to be effective. Please focus on the issues raised in the complaint and answer and on diffs which illustrate behavior which relates to the issues.

If you disagree with some evidence you see here, please cite the evidence in your own section and provide counter-evidence, or an explanation of why the evidence is misleading. Do not edit within the evidence section of any other user.

Be aware that the Arbitrators may at times rework this page to try to make it more coherent. If you are a participant in the case or a third party, please don't try to refactor the page, let the Arbitrators do it. If you object to evidence which is inserted by other participants or third parties please cite the evidence and voice your objections within your own section of the page. It is especially important to not remove evidence presented by others. If something is put in the wrong place, please leave it for the arbitrators to move.

Evidence presented by The Literate Engineer

17 July 2005

• 21:43 CDT
  • 2 minor WP:civ violations (judgmental edit summary, ill-considered accusation) on talk page:[2]

20 July 2005

• 01:40 CDT
  • Bad-faith RfA nomination of other user: [3] (see [4], [5], [6])

21 July 2005

• 22:54 CDT
  • Edit summary disparaging article topic (WP:civ/NPOV violation):[7]

• 22:56 CDT
  • Creation of talk page with content violating established arbcom principle: [8]

23 July 2005

• 14:54 CDT
  • Gives appearance of sockpuppetry in RFA vote: [9]

• 22:20 CDT
  • Disruption of VfD (keep vote either bad-faith or misleading sarcastic delete vote):[10]

3 August 2005

• 11:23 CDT (follows 11:21 CDT)
  • Unspecific disparagement of article as justification for template:totallydisputed: [11] (follows [12])

5 August 2005

• 23:28 CDT
  • Presumed sockpuppetry in self-nomination at RfA: [13] (see [14])

6 August 2005

• 00:47 CDT
  • Disruption of RFA by proving bad-faith (self-)nomination: [15]

• 02:57 CDT
  • Personal attack on article talk page: [16]

9 August 2005

• 13:01 CDT and 13:06
  • Minor WP:civ violations at his RFC:[17] & [18]

16 August 2005

• 01:30 CDT
  • Disruption of deletion processes by applying speedy and vfd tags to article: [19]

• 01:42 CDT
  • Presumably bad-faith VfD nomination: [20]

• 01:46 CDT
  • Presumably bad-faith VfD nomination: [21]

Evidence presented by Casito

I am operating under the assumption that Rainbowwarrior1977, SamuraiBoywithaDrugProblem, CelineDionFan82 (and others) are sock-puppets of Musachachado. All four use the same MO and edit the same pages. Furthermore, he has admitted on several occations (described below) that this is true.

5 July, as Musachachado

• 03:23 (UTC)
  • Marked NASCAR for speedy deletion within 5 minutes of his first edit [22]. Continued with further template abuse [23] and addition of nonsence [24].

8 Jul, as Musachachado

• 05:25
  • Added demeaning comment to Seven Seas disguised as a minor edit [25].

14 Jul, as Musachachado

• 05:05
  • Sneaky vandalism to Kathleen Willey involving a nonsence German translation [26] and a bogus source [27].

16 Jul, as Musachachado

• 18:12
  • Personal attack against Saforrest who accused him of a copyvio. [28]
• 18:14
  • Template abuse to Anglo-saxon hunting [29]
• 18:26
  • Listed Ainu people at VFD; claimed article was plagiarized from a public domain source [30], [31].
• 18:34
  • Made legal threat in edit summary. [32]
• 18:52
  • Clamed to be a copyright law expert [33].
• 18:55
  • Called Pharos a "dumbass" [34].
• 19:04
  • Called Pharos a "plagarist/thief/vandal person" [35].

18 Jul, as SamuraiBoywithaDrugProblem

• 02:15
  • First edit as User:SamuraiBoywithaDrugProblem sock-puppet.
• 02:16
  • Claimed to have "descended from Burakumin and Ainu peoples" [36].
• 05:22
  • Claimed to "have a MA in medieval history from Boston College ... and JD (Law Degree) from NYU." Admitted to being a sock-puppet of User:CelineDionFan82 [37].
• 06:02
  • Accused me of some legal gobbledygook [38].
• 06:14
  • Juvanile vandalism of Swiss cheese [39].
• 06:33
  • Called Pharos "dense". Admitted to the Swiss cheese vandalism [40].
• 15:53
  • Called Pharos narrow minded, and "perhaps angry at some unspecified longings in your subconsience" [41].
• 21:29
  • Called me a "bloody fellow" and claimed that I made legal threats against him. [42]
• 21:32
  • Added a silly German statment to his post definitively linking him to User:Musachachado [43].
• 23:15
  • Called mikkalai a "known Communist" and a "young grasshopper". [44]

18 Jul, as Rainbowwarrior1977

• 2:48
  • First edit as User:Rainbowwarrior1977. Called Geogre a "nincompoop" who is "busy puttering about with his Dungeons and Dragons nineteen-side dice" [[45]].
• 3:37
  • Admitted to being a sock-puppet of User:Musachachado [46].
• 3:49
  • Serious sneaky vandalism to Cathy Cox disguised as minor edits [47], [48], [49].

19 Jul, as Rainbowwarrior1977

• 3:35
  • Accused me again of legal threats [50].
• 3:39
  • Accused me for a third time of making legal threats. Called me a "cloying fellow" [51].
• 15:39
  • More legal nonsence on my talk page. Claimed to be from "Khazakstan [sic]" [52]. I responded, telling him never to post on my talk page again [53].

20 Jul

• 06:37
  • Nominated Purplefeltangel for adminship. He continued creating trouble on that page for quite some time. I did not follow that mess.

21 Jul

• 16:08
  • Posted on my talk page against my expressed wishes [54].

22 Jul

• 03:28
  • Reverted my talk page, calling me a "Chump" in the edit summary [55].
• 03:46
  • Claimed to be 15 years old [56].
• 04:22
  • Reverted my talk page, saying that I "cant [sic] handle the truth" and threatened to "report me" [57].
• 05:23
  • Added a nonsense template to my talk page [58]. Struck text [59], listed my talk page for speedy deletion, calling me a "huge dork" [60], and posted against my wishes yet again [61].

6 Aug

• 08:38
  • Posted again on my talk page against my wishes [62], adjusting the font [63].

I suspect that some of the further vandalism to my user page was caused by him, though I have no evidence besides a Boston College IP.

Evidence presented by Essjay

I apologize that I seem to have abandoned this case; with real world responsibilities, and recent stresses leading to a Wikibreak, I simply have not had the time to recategorize the RfC I filed into the ArbCom format. I second the evidence presented above, and would like to draw the attention of the Arbitrators to the original RfC: Wikipedia:Requests for comment/Rainbowwarrior1977.

Evidence presented by {your user name}

<day1> <month>

• <timestamp1>
  • What happened.

• <timestamp2>
  • What happened.

• <timestamp3>
  • What happened.

<day2> <month>

• <timestamp1>
  • What happened.

• <timestamp2>
  • What happened.

• <timestamp3>
  • What happened.